I have been paying very careful attention to men and their facial hair lately. These are my conclusions:
Clean shave: A man cannot go wrong by being clean-shaven. A clean shave is the James Bond of facial hairstyles: sophisticated, powerful, and ready for action. No matter what a man's face looks like, whether he's got a strong jaw or no jaw, chiseled cheekbones or John McCain cheekbags, he looks good with a clean shave.
Shadow: Scruff is also hot. The secret reason I (am I'm assuming other women, and men) like a clean-shaven man: The next-morning scruff. It's the male equivalent of bedroom hair, and makes us feel like we're seeing a secret extra-sexy side of you. George Michael knew how to work it in the '80s, and it's still a look that makes hearts beat.
Full beard: Meh*. Awesome if you're a Catholic priest in Northern California, Uncle Jesse, the model for the line drawings of the '70s edition of The Joy of Sex, or a homicidal maniac. Otherwise you just kind of look like you don't care, or you're spending way too much time planning your upcoming expedition to the South Pole to think about anything else.
Full beard with long hair: No. Unless you are also carrying a bass guitar in a bag and have a sexy South American accent and smile at me while you're waiting for your coffee at the place across the street from my apartment. Then yes.
Mustache alone: Are you Tom Selleck? Clark Gable? If the answer to these questions is "no," then you cannot wear a mustache alone. I'm sorry. You may, however, move straight into the Zone of Hottness with...
A goatee: My personal kryptonite, a goatee just says, "I'm a little bit troublesome, in the good way." It's a statement, and looks just as good with a tuxedo or a ripped T-shirt, on carpenters, CTOs, college professors, chefs, basically anyone. It frames a man's face the way shaped eyebrows shape a woman's.
Verdict: For maximum appeal, men should go with a clean shave or a goatee, and avoid a full beard or mustache.
Agreement? Dissenting opinions?
*What is it with "meh" this week? First Mark Peters gets explanatory and funny on it, then Ben Zimmer gets referee-ish on it. I never thought people didn't think it was a word, as my friends and I have been saying--not typing, saying--it for at least 15 years. Don't hate the playas, people; hate the game: New words are all around us, all the time.